Thursday, 27 May 2010

Stephen Ireland - should he stay or should he go?

The Stephen Ireland story is edging out as an early contender for City's most protracted transfer dealing of the summer. Last summer we had Eto'o and Terry, the winter before was Kaka, but the early summer murmurs point to something that is far more likely to happen - the exit of last year's player of the season.

Roque Santa Cruz went some way to confirming how unsettled Ireland is by urging him to stay in the press today: "He is a very nice guy and a fantastic player also, so I think everybody at the club would be very disappointed to see him leaving. He is a great talent." Whilst going on to reveal some of his own insecurities by suggesting his, and Ireland's, worries about incoming replacements.

On the merit of this season's peformances they both have reason to fear replacements. Santa Cruz has never been fit enough to prove his worth to the team (prompting questions about whether he ever will be) and Ireland has struggled to regain his place after a series injuries and an early season health scare.

Reports are that Ireland has handed in a transfer request and City are stepping up their search for replacements, but the fact is we needed a creative replacement for Ireland anyway - and perhaps his knowledge of this has caused his recent disillusionment. Ireland lacks the mental attributes to play in the centre of midfield so, realistically, the only spot he vies for is the free role with Carlos Tevez - and with a plummet in commitment, Ireland has never looked like challenging him for his place. With the plaudits of last season, Ireland will not be happy to be labelled as cover in the side he was player of the season in. City have needed someone with creativity to sit alongside Barry or de Jong, but Ireland wilts under the responsibility of such a role.

Nedum, in his infamous Soccer AM interview, described Ireland as the best player he has ever played with - citing his "unbelievable tecchers" (technique to you and me!). Which introduces the conundrum of why the best players aren't the best players. In an idealistic world Ireland would be the best player in City's current team - he does have unbelievable technique, he has the ability to pick passes that others don't see - but as Ireland's performances last season proved - it needs to be coupled with the right mentality and work ethic to be effective. The other two players with the greatest technical ability over the last ten years are probably Robinho and Elano - and whilst they are both capable of breathtaking pieces of football, it cannot be argued that they have heads for the Premier League. The same perhaps goes for Ireland.

Or does it? The most frustrating aspect of his performances this season has been our knowledge of his performances last season. If last season hadn't happened, the Ireland of this campaign wouldn't have raised any eyebrows. He has still showed the occasional glimpses of magic this season but he has looked like the uncertain player of before - incapable of playing the simple pass and more comfortable on the peripheries of the action. People speculate about his mental strength but he was certainly capable of reacting in the right way to being down the pecking order under Hughes - he didn't start last season in the squad remember - but perhaps, like Nedum, he doesn't feel like he has another fight left in him - the idea that one fight should be enough to establish a first team place. The competition is getting stronger all the time but, if Ireland had the resilience, a player of his natural abilities should believe himself up for the challenge. Perhaps it is exactly this lack of resilience that will prove to rule Nedum and Ireland out of the high standard of football the club are striving to achieve. Maybe Ireland just needs an 8-1 drubbing somewhere to refocus him.

In the Guardian, Daniel Taylor suggested last week that Ireland "is renowned for being so sensitive when things are not going well his transfer request was partly expected behind the scenes." And this represents the crux of the problem. Mancini was right to suggest it relies on Ireland's head. If the staff at City can be confident of a rejuvenation of Ireland, then it would be foolish to sell him - but it is precisely his problems that could prevent him from fulfilling his potential. He seems popular enough amongst the players that a protracted transfer wrangle would be detrimental to the squad (especially if he is set to be bartered against other Premier League midfielders - Milner and Arteta, for example), so a speedy resolution may be better for all parties - and only the future will tell whether he will come back to haunt us or drift into legend as a one-season wonder.

Tuesday, 25 May 2010

Mancini and the spectre of Mourinho

Mourinho looms large over the footballing world at the moment - bigger than clubs, more ambitious than any player, he is swiftly becoming the most powerful force in world football. Little wonder then that his name becomes entangled in the midst of one of the world's most ambitious football clubs. For Roberto Mancini, his successor at Inter will be on his mind more than most.

Mancini has been at pains this season to make sure his achievements at Inter are not lost underneath the supreme success of Jose Mourinho. Asked if he built the foundations of the team, Mancini said he also 'built the roof.' Whilst to some he seems to be claiming a slice of Mourinho's success, he is probably just making sure that his significant achievements don't go forgotten. Before Mancini's first Inter title (amongst the Calciopoli scandal), Inter had gone 17 years without winning the Scudetto - which for a club of Inter's size is remarkable (the longest 'barren' spell in their history since they won their first title in 1910). Inter have won every title since, including the following two under Mancini. On top of this, Mancini's first of two Coppa Italia triumphs was the club's first for 23 years. After 17 years without a domestic trophy of any description, Mancini was hired by Moratti for his record of success and he delivered instantly with seven trophies in four years.

It is true that two of Mancini's title campaigns benefited from the Calciopoli scandal (Juventus were stripped of the title in 2005-2006, and subsequent points deductions reduced the competition in 2006-2007), but it cannot be argued that Mancini didn't re-establish Inter at the top of the Italian game. Mourinho was brought in to take them to the next level - the European success that Moratti wanted - and he obviously succeeded. Yet out of the Champions League starting eleven, five were players who arrived under Mancini: Julio Cesar (from Flamengo), Maicon (from Monaco), Esteban Cambiasso and Walter Samuel (from Real Madrid), and Cristian Chivu (from Roma). These players represent the defensive heart of the team and Mourinho has built his team around this solidity - adding the guile and creativity of Milito and Sneijder, in particular, to produce the ruthless side capable of unpicking the world's best. So whilst Inter's recent success belongs to Mourinho, Mancini deserves credit for putting the club back to winning ways and creating the foundations (and the roof!) for success.

Mourinho continued to haunt Mancini after his arrival at City. The current City fans can probably be cut roughly into the following categories: the grateful, the disillusioned, and those bloated by the club's quick ascent (most of us are probably guilty of all three!). It is the last category that push Mourinho into this scenario (albeit with a lot of help from the press). Despite Mourinho's unwavering ambition to complete a footballing grandslam, a minority of fans still thought Jose should be the man replacing Hughes. Although the constant rumour mills often distort the type of people interested in coming to City, we are still a growing force and, whilst Mourinho could be interested when he makes his final prophesised return to English football, he was never going to take a step back amidst his run for global domination and footballing immortality.

I know that some of the calls for Mourinho were born out of frustration over Hughes' exit - the feeling that if we are getting rid of Hughes we should be replacing him with the world's best. But now, with Mourinho ready to move onto his next stage, Mancini can finally settle down to do what he has needed to do from the offset: build the team he wants and prepare himself for what lies ahead.

Saturday, 22 May 2010

Crunch week for Barry and Johnson

Of course, it is crunch week for everyone involved in the England set up, but the two big City stories to come out of the England camp (discounting Milner transfer speculation) are Adam Johnson's sustained charge for a place and Gareth Barry's late fitness call.

To cap off a quite remarkable 2010 for Johnson, the papers and the insiders are all unanimous in their praise for his shows in training this week. Many pick him out as the star performer and almost all reserve a special mention for his impressive displays. Blue Days has been looking at the reaction in more detail in an insightful piece. To add to the sources found there, including this from the Mirror: "Playing on the left wing, he terrorised Liverpool veteran Jamie Carragher and rained in a string of pinpoint crosses," today's Guardian and the BBC's England blog, amongst others, both single him out for his performances.

So, for Johnson, half the job is done. Speaking last month, Capello said: "Johnson has caught my eye. Now it's important he gets some international experience." Which indicates, not only that he will feature in Monday's friendly with Mexico, but that a lot will ride on how well he performs.

If Johnson can prove himself on the international stage, it will be a remarkable ascent from the player who only moved back to the Premier League on the first of February. A storming entrance eclipsed only by Walcott's suprise inclusion four years ago. Unlike Walcott in Germany, Johnson would have earned his place on merit and could well fill a spot that has been vacant for England for many years. Through years of bemoaning Gigg's defection back to Wales, Johnson could be the answer England has been waiting for. Whether this tournament has come a little too soon rests on this coming week but, after impressing in training, he is half way there.

Monday is also decision day for Gareth Barry. Who, in his ten year England career, has never made a World Cup, dipping in and out of the squad at the wrong moments for 2002 and 2006. He will be 33 when the next one comes around and whilst he is very much part of Capello's first eleven now, he would not be able to guarantee that next time round. He talks extensively about how much the World Cup would mean to him this summer in several interviews in the Saturday papers but it would also be a huge loss for England if he cannot make it.

Here's hoping for both of them.

Wednesday, 19 May 2010

Ibrahimovic to be this summer's marquee purchase?

All the little whispers about Ibrahimovic are set to explode after Barcelona confirmed the signing of David Villa this lunchtime. Given the style Barca play, this move effectively relegates last summer's star signing to the bench and, after an unconvincing season, this could lead to the Barca management wanting to cash in.

A few weeks ago, the Spanish football expert Sid Lowe, speaking on the Guardian's Football Weekly podcast, suggested City as the only possible destination. The implications of his words are: one, large amounts of money would be involved, and two, it would be a risk - and judging on previous windows City are thought to be cavalier enough to take this on.

There is no doubt that Ibrahimovic has unbelievable ability but the worry is that his languid style, that frustrates fans in Spain, would be swallowed up by the pace of the Premier League. In that mould, he has always reminded me of a far more talented Berbatov - but as we've had the pleasure of seeing, this doesn't always work in the Premier League. Although, the sheer ability of the man, and his consistently high goal scoring record (he has still scored 21 goals this season) would obviously benefit most sides in the world.

One of the major remaining questions here though, as always, is why would he want to join City? Without Champions League, City do not offer the level of football Ibra is used to, and this is a major stumbling block. He is already on huge wages at Barca and I don't think the City management (no longer as intent on making the status-signing) would break the bank in his favour, so the usual bargaining isn't there. At 28, he has already achieved a lot in the game - so the bargaining stand point that he could 'help write the history' of a club may appeal to him, but only if he is convinced it will happen quickly.

As I see it, the only factor in favour of City is Roberto Mancini. When Mancini arrived at City, journalists sought out Ibrahimovic's opinion pretty quickly:

"City want to become a big team, and in order to do that you need a manager who knows how to run one," he said. "I think City have already learned that you don't become Barcelona or Inter Milan overnight. It takes a lot of time, but it also takes the right man in charge. Roberto will change the mentality of the club overnight, he is a big manager and the players will learn that very quickly."

The whole article can be found on SkySports. Ibrahimovic scored 32 goals in 53 Serie A games under Mancini and he obviously has fond memories of his time with him. With the murmurs of players that are unhappy under Mancini, Roberto could well look to buy in someone (like he did with Vieira) who he knows he can rely on.

It seems a very unlikely deal, but City are in a better position this year than the side that finished tenth last season - and even then it appeared City came close to signing some stars of the world game - Kaka, Eto'o and Terry, in particular went on long enough to suggest consideration from those names. Whether Ibrahimovic would be good for the team dynamics is another question altogether.

On the subject of Ibrahimovic, it is always nice to see this goal he scored for Ajax:

Sunday, 16 May 2010

Nedum on his way

After seeing Nedum's interview on Soccer AM yesterday, it seems clear to me he is on his way out of the club. Normally so measured, positive and even intellectual for a footballer, his anti-regime comments were not those of a player looking to step up his challenge for a place next season.

The very fact he has let his guard down suggests he thinks there is nothing left to protect in his City career - which is a great shame. You can understand Nedum's frustrations. Here is a rare thing in a player nowadays - a lifelong fan of the club he plays for, and you feel he has had more resilience in fighting for his position than other players might have done when found in the same situation. With almost all the in-coming managers of recent seasons, Nedum has found himself at first unfavoured only to win back his place on the merit of his solid performances.

You would have thought, had he not been plagued by injuries throughout his young career, he would have gone on to establish himself as, not only a City regular, but possibly, and by virtue of regular football, an international contender for this summer. But it wasn't to be, and now, with the constant influx of replacements, he evidently thinks it is the end of his City career.

I do think his comments were born more out of frustration than by clear thought though. To suggest he was on the brink of a first team return under Hughes is a little fanciful. He did have injury problems under Hughes, as he has had under Mancini, yet he still has featured more often under Mancini. To suggest Hughes may have been on the verge of putting him in is also sadly unlikely, because in the last weeks of Hughes' time at the club, he had already spoken of trying to sign more defenders in January - in an attempt to shore up the area that ultimately cost him his job. Had Hughes been trusted with more money for defenders over January, Nedum may well have been in an even worse situation.

Part of his frustration may have also been from the perceived decline of his generation this season (something that hasn't just happened under Mancini, but Hughes also - it is easy to blame it on the person in charge when it comes to a head). Ireland ('the best player I have ever played with') has had a tough season, but I don't think anyone could argue his performances have merited his inclusion - he is undoubtedly an outstanding talent and one I would like to remain at the club, but it has been a difficult season for him to say the least - again, slightly surprisingly, Ireland blamed Hughes for his form when Mancini arrived.

Micah has also been drifting in and out, but he has had his share of injuries since Mancini's arrival, and probably looks a bit more assured when he has played. Although he is not quite his generation of academy graduates but very much a part of them, Shaun Wright-Phillips is the only player to actually decline under Mancini - still a pacy threat from the bench, he has gone from a Hughes-favourite to a squad player very quickly. The fortunes of all his contemporaries will undoubtedly have affected Nedum - as it stands, there doesn't appear to be much hope for them - but to be so outwardly anti-Mancini is probably missing the point a little. Although, to be fair to Nedum, we don't know what goes on behind the scenes.

Finally there were his words about Lescott, saying Mancini cost him his World Cup place by declaring him unfit for the final two games even though he had just returned to training. Realistically, having not played for months, Lescott had an incredibly slim chance of making Capello's 30 even if he had managed two games towards the end - other players had made their claim by then (Dawson and King in particular). So, for Mancini not to involve a partially-fit Lescott in our biggest game of the season is hardly surprising.

I can understand Nedum's frustration - he has put so much into the club - work and emotionally - but I thought it was a shame he had to publicly defame the management. I have great respect for him and I do think he will become a top-class player if he gets regular football, but I'm afraid he may be looking to get that regular football away from City next year. I would love him to stay, but with the prospect of further centre-backs arriving, this could be one fight too many for him. Either way, if Mancini doesn't like him, as Nedum suggests, I think it is safe to say it is reciprocal.

You can watch a clip of the video over at Bitter and Blue.

Saturday, 15 May 2010

Transfers: Positions to target

Despite the escalating rumours of another mass overhaul this pre-season, City are not in the position that they were last summer and a mass turnover is not essential. Whereas last summer most of the squad needed looking at, this summer three or four players in key positions would help push City onto the next level. For me, the priorities are the following positions:


1. A ball-playing central midfielder.

Everytime we play a well-organised team I come on here and bemoan our lack of incision. If a team comes to Eastlands and concentrates on frustrating City before unleashing their counter-attack, like Everton and Tottenham, then we have no one who can cut through.

Stephen Ireland has the passing ability but he is limited positionally. If he is playing in the free-role behind the strikers, he is fine - but give him some responsibility in the centre and his game shrinks with it. His lack of success this season, as much as anything else, has come from being in direct competition for Tevez's role.

When Hughes arrived at City he needed to address City's soft centre and this he did with the arrivals of De Jong and Kompany - but with Elano gone, Michael Johnson perennially injured, and Ireland off the boil, it has left City with no one in the middle who can pick a quick pass.

So, we play our best against teams who attack us, allowing the pace of our counter attack to wreak havoc - but as teams have become wise to that, we often struggle to unpick them.

A goal-scoring midfielder or a box-to-box player who can do it all should be the summer's priority.

Possible targets: Marek Hamsik, James Milner, Mesut Ozil, Fernando Gago, Lassana Diarra.


2. Left-back

There are already doubts about Bridge's performances when he does play but regardless of that, we cannot rely on him to be fit for the majority of a season. With all the added games that the Europa League brings, we will at least need a cover that Mancini can trust - his picking of Zabaleta there over Garrido and Sylvinho suggests he doesn't trust those two - and better, a player who can challenge Bridge's place.

Possible targets: Juan Manuel Vargas, David Luiz.


3. Centre-forward

After having an embarrassment of riches in the attacking department at the start of the season - all the pre-season speculation was about how Hughes could keep them all happy - we have now been left a bit bare.

Tevez and Adebayor are the only first-team strikers you can rely on to be fit. They are both high quality players, but neither of them are really box players. Adebayor, for all his height, shies away from aerial challenges and is much happier dropping deep and drifting wide, and whilst Tevez can never be said to shy away, he is also happier playing the deeper role. This leaves us with noone to profit from our wing-play - so a striker that can lead the line would be preferable. However, if not, we could still do with adding some genuine competition for Adebayor.

With Roque, as much as I think there is a good player hidden away in there, his injury situation has gone beyond a joke and whether he will ever be able to return to full fitness and form is a big question.

Possible targets: Gonzalo Higuain, Mario Balotelli, Fernando Torres (?!).


There could be the arrival of some surprises, but on top of these positions we only really need squad depth and competition. Jerome Boateng could take the right-back slot, for example, whilst challenging for his preferred central role. It is likely to be another busy summer with both ins and outs, but we shouldn't need too much maintenance this time round.

Wednesday, 12 May 2010

The transfer season without Champions League

Before we failed to make it, everyone's main concern about not qualifying for the Champions League was that we wouldn't be able to attract the world's best players. It is easy to add the caveat now, but it would perhaps be more correct to have said the world's best established players - which isn't exactly the same thing.

Of course, players in the prime of their career or world-renown will see arriving at a team who are without the world's most glamorous club competition as a step back. Their status in the game has been reached by achieving already and their only real motivation for such a move would most likely be for financial purposes. The hunger of these players (and you could use Robinho as an example) is sometimes questionable - even when the team is firing.

Evidently, all this is easy to say on the back of missing out on the Champions League and who wouldn't want to see the world's stars in their team, but the transfer strategy that Mancini and the Corporation Couple may now be forced to look at is probably the best, and the most sustainable, for the club. If rumours and hearsay are to believed, City are concentrating their considerable financial strength on acquiring the best of the world's (or Serie A's) emerging talent.

Today's rumours link City with Hamsik, Balotelli and David Luiz, among others. Big name players already, at big clubs, but all young (22, 19 and 23 respectively). Unlike the players who would come in in their late 20s, who have done it all and act accordingly, these players are still young and, to use that word again, hungry to prove themselves at the top level (I am talking generally of course, as many watchers of Serie A will argue Balotelli doesn't always look all that motivated!).

We would be getting up-and-coming stars who could be the spine of the team for years to come - a continuity that the team would need to succeed and build. It is no use signing big-name stars if they are disinterested and will only look for move after a short time. The signing of Robinho, who I am actually a fan of, was a huge statement to the footballing world - but more galacticos wouldn't necessarily help a team that seems to be growing in spirit and togetherness (bar a few exceptions).

I think Hamsik would be an excellent signing, if possible, as he is the sort of goal-scoring midfielder that City are crying out for at the moment. There are talks in Italy that he is about to agree terms to a new contract with Napoli, but as Mancini has said he wants to get his deals in place before the World Cup, City may be able to present an alternative offer.

At times this season it has been obvious that we were a team swiftly thrown together and, despite the disappointment of missing out on the Champions League, every year of consolidation will make us stronger. Obviously, I won't be complaining if we sign a Gerrard or a Torres, but I certainly won't be complaining if we don't.

*As I was typing this, Football Italia have quoted Balotelli's agent as saying there is no chance of him moving to City - saying that no discussions will be held til after the Champions League final. Although, having kept up with Balotelli's agents declarations about his client, this doesn't necessarily mean a deal is not in the offing. His words are fairly strong this time though.