Sunday 16 May 2010

Nedum on his way

After seeing Nedum's interview on Soccer AM yesterday, it seems clear to me he is on his way out of the club. Normally so measured, positive and even intellectual for a footballer, his anti-regime comments were not those of a player looking to step up his challenge for a place next season.

The very fact he has let his guard down suggests he thinks there is nothing left to protect in his City career - which is a great shame. You can understand Nedum's frustrations. Here is a rare thing in a player nowadays - a lifelong fan of the club he plays for, and you feel he has had more resilience in fighting for his position than other players might have done when found in the same situation. With almost all the in-coming managers of recent seasons, Nedum has found himself at first unfavoured only to win back his place on the merit of his solid performances.

You would have thought, had he not been plagued by injuries throughout his young career, he would have gone on to establish himself as, not only a City regular, but possibly, and by virtue of regular football, an international contender for this summer. But it wasn't to be, and now, with the constant influx of replacements, he evidently thinks it is the end of his City career.

I do think his comments were born more out of frustration than by clear thought though. To suggest he was on the brink of a first team return under Hughes is a little fanciful. He did have injury problems under Hughes, as he has had under Mancini, yet he still has featured more often under Mancini. To suggest Hughes may have been on the verge of putting him in is also sadly unlikely, because in the last weeks of Hughes' time at the club, he had already spoken of trying to sign more defenders in January - in an attempt to shore up the area that ultimately cost him his job. Had Hughes been trusted with more money for defenders over January, Nedum may well have been in an even worse situation.

Part of his frustration may have also been from the perceived decline of his generation this season (something that hasn't just happened under Mancini, but Hughes also - it is easy to blame it on the person in charge when it comes to a head). Ireland ('the best player I have ever played with') has had a tough season, but I don't think anyone could argue his performances have merited his inclusion - he is undoubtedly an outstanding talent and one I would like to remain at the club, but it has been a difficult season for him to say the least - again, slightly surprisingly, Ireland blamed Hughes for his form when Mancini arrived.

Micah has also been drifting in and out, but he has had his share of injuries since Mancini's arrival, and probably looks a bit more assured when he has played. Although he is not quite his generation of academy graduates but very much a part of them, Shaun Wright-Phillips is the only player to actually decline under Mancini - still a pacy threat from the bench, he has gone from a Hughes-favourite to a squad player very quickly. The fortunes of all his contemporaries will undoubtedly have affected Nedum - as it stands, there doesn't appear to be much hope for them - but to be so outwardly anti-Mancini is probably missing the point a little. Although, to be fair to Nedum, we don't know what goes on behind the scenes.

Finally there were his words about Lescott, saying Mancini cost him his World Cup place by declaring him unfit for the final two games even though he had just returned to training. Realistically, having not played for months, Lescott had an incredibly slim chance of making Capello's 30 even if he had managed two games towards the end - other players had made their claim by then (Dawson and King in particular). So, for Mancini not to involve a partially-fit Lescott in our biggest game of the season is hardly surprising.

I can understand Nedum's frustration - he has put so much into the club - work and emotionally - but I thought it was a shame he had to publicly defame the management. I have great respect for him and I do think he will become a top-class player if he gets regular football, but I'm afraid he may be looking to get that regular football away from City next year. I would love him to stay, but with the prospect of further centre-backs arriving, this could be one fight too many for him. Either way, if Mancini doesn't like him, as Nedum suggests, I think it is safe to say it is reciprocal.

You can watch a clip of the video over at Bitter and Blue.

20 comments:

  1. very good article..I saw his soccer am interview and I was disappointed. It seems Mancini isn't the most popular guy among the players. I think it's crazy Boyata, as talented as he is should not be ahead of Nedum. I would be gutted to see any of our academy grads leave the club

    ReplyDelete
  2. you simply can't tolerate this from players, it lacks professional attitude and discipline. These players are beginning to irritate me. What irked me more, was the lack of validity in Nedums comments, as mentioned, the lescott case is a farce. To mention that as a criticism towards management lacks common sense and perspective.

    I have no affection for these acad grads, Steven ireland in particular.

    ReplyDelete
  3. nedum is a disgrace and shows that he lacks the mental attitude to be a top class player.

    To say ireland was the best player he has ever played with, when Tevez, Ade and even Robinho are a class above, shows his acceptance of us being a club who make up the numbers.

    Sorry Ned, but we have moved on from that and hopefully we will move you on asap"!!!!!!!

    ReplyDelete
  4. Sad loser, jobs for the boys brigade, move on lad and take your clicks with you.

    ReplyDelete
  5. his frustration is obvious and understandable but he's not done himself any favours saying "I just don't think he likes me"- live on telly!!! He'll move on, as will we- hope he gets plenty of 1st team football wherever he goes.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Have to agree with most comments,i have a lot of time for Ned,as he has always come across well whenever interviewed but he has just fuelled the redtops with a load of sour bile.Its time to move on the likes of Ned and superman as they just dont seem to have enough fight in them,while on this subject neither do Toure,bridge or Adebayor,but i think im only writing what Mancini already knows

    ReplyDelete
  7. He's not good enough. I've heard some of his moaning through another player I know and he's not got much common sense for a bright lad.

    Move him on.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Can't believe the hate on here. Nedum is a top lad' I've met him. Very down to earth and has a degree at University.

    He hasn't been given his chance this season and i think it's a real shame, he's a top player and if he goes I'll be devestated.

    Lloyd - man-city-issues.blogspot.com

    ReplyDelete
  9. He may be a top lad Scragg and he may be academically intelligent. However, what he said on Soccer Am was inexcusable. Most of his complaints were ridiculous and made no sense and furthermore the things he said can only do harm to the club he supposedly loves. If he wants to leave, I wouldn't blame him, he has never really been first choice and clearly it is what he needs but he could have done it without saying those things.

    ReplyDelete
  10. exactly. Top lad perhaps, but he's certainly doing know one any favours with these comments. Ill thought and judged and he should be made to regret them...

    ReplyDelete
  11. Martin living in Birmingham
    I was quite shocked at the comments. At first i thought i had misheard but as they went on it was clear it was no slip but an attack on the club and Mancini in particular. I agree with what has been said in the article about the inaccuracy in the comments. I also thought his whole demeanour was very poor, he was not concentrating and not very interested at all.
    Very sad and i fear that means the end for the one Man City home grown talent and fan in the team.

    ReplyDelete
  12. I was so shocked by Nedum's comments too. I've always had the highest regard for him, both as a player and a seemingly intelligent person. But his interview seemed so immature, and so unwise. If he has a problem at City, then he should discuss it with City's management, never air it in the press. Very sad and very disappointed.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Comments made as a result of frustration with his situation. Not perhaps the wisest things to have said and insofar as Lescott's position something of a mystery.
    IF Capello had wanted Lescott in the squad then surely Mancini's advocacy or otherwise is ultimately inconsequential. Capello would have asked Lescott about his fitness and his ability to play in the Tournament.
    If Lescott was positive then Capello would have
    pursued medical opinion as confirmation before making his mind up, that is IF he had truly wanted Joleon.
    I like Ned, but he made a bit of an ass of himself. I don't think he will be on the payroll for much longer

    ReplyDelete
  14. Ah the usual bollox from the party line jumpers. Nedum did nothing more than speak openly and honestly. Personally, I have no problem whatsoever with it, but it seems anyone that speaks against Mancini is vilified. Nedum is not the only lad at City to be marginalised big time under Mancini, but don`t let the comments from a through and through blue inside the club detract you from blind hero worship. This club becomes increasingly soul less and ostracised from the many that have followed through thin and thin. Is this the City you love any more? Mancini works only for himself and the longer it goes on the more obvious it will become. His man management skills are zero and I personally wish the twat had stayed in Italy.

    ReplyDelete
  15. I`m 100% with Scragg. Some of you arseholes make me sick. What you should be doing is taking notice of the most reliable and intelligent guys at the club, but all you want to do is have a juvenile pop because you`d rather pretend all is rosy in the garden. Dumb shits the lot of you.

    ReplyDelete
  16. I have done nothing but praise Onuoha for the last two years (even got No. 4 on my home shirt). Unlike some I couldn't care less about his academic achievements or if he's got an IQ of 180. I've just always thought he was dependable, consistent and mature on the field.

    The issue I have with him now is that you can't go on TV and say things like that about your boss. Whether he was speaking honestly and frankly, doesn't matter. You just don't do it.

    This is going on too much at City and it has to be stamped out. I'd hate for it to Nedum who suffers but if I'm Mancini I would make an example of the people who do it - not by selling them on and allowing them their fat signing on cheques, but by letting them languish in the reserves for a season. He has to start getting control of the dressing room and as we have seen with Ferguson, Wenger and Mourinho this means ruling with an iron fist. A football team is not a democracy and it's certainly not a socialist commune - it's a dictatorship, and the sooner our players understand that, the better we will all be.

    ReplyDelete
  17. I'm not 100% with Scragg. Being an intelligent, top lad only makes his words more baffling. If there is one thing I learned at uni then it is that it's no guarantee for common sense!

    Nedum obviously went on there with an agenda and the point is, this to the bloke who says "he's speaking his mind" - he didn't even make any sense at all.

    I think people are angry coz it is almost like a betrayal. Onuoha is like one of us amongst the team - someone who has what's best for the club at heart - yet here he is acting out of pure self-interest. What does he gain from those comments? If you are in a team, you simply don't say those sort of things publicly. Poor show. Bye bye Nedum.

    ReplyDelete
  18. Afraid it with Nedum it is too often
    cometh the hour - cometh the injury . One of the previous regime commented that he was convinced it was a protection mechanism because he feared he wouldn't keep a regular place.

    ReplyDelete
  19. The fact is Nedum featured more this season under Mancini than he did Hughes. These comments are completely unfounded!

    ReplyDelete
  20. Shore up not sure up:) paragraph 4

    ReplyDelete