Saturday, 18 September 2010

FC Energy Drink 0 - 2 City: Match Report and Player Ratings

 
City's Thursday evening introduction to the group stages of the Europa League was one of those games that could have delighted the circling press:  huge excitement in Austria, a fairly low key team yet the only team to win every game in the group stages last season, an allegedly difficult playing surface.  The ingredients were there, but it turned out to be a fairly routine victory in the end.

It was a good night for the players striving to cement a place in the first eleven.  David Silva, subject to a lot of praise over the past week, got his first goal for the club, is beginning to look up to pace, and should now be ready to join the Premier League campaign in earnest.  

Jo made his first start for City since 2008 and capped it with a goal and an assist - and helped free Tevez to play his favourite role.  If he is to play more football for City, then the goal will do him good - and he looked visibly exhausted by the end of the match, such is the rarity of him completing ninety minutes of football.  

The other player hoping to retain his place was Wayne Bridge, who, to the suprise of the statistic compilers, completed a cross in the build up to Silva's goal in the eighth minute.  He wasn't unduly tested defensively but his adventurous style of play hinted at how Mancini will eventually hope to use Kolarov and Boateng - a tight midfield with attackingly effective full-backs. 

It was the first we have seen of the diamond formation that we saw a lot of in pre-season and you can't help but feel we will see a lot more of it once everyone is up to speed - perhaps with Silva, Tevez and Balotelli as the top three. 

Kolo Toure and Vincent Kompany's partnership continues to grow, and both were impressive again when called upon.  

Milner talked about one of the positives of the quantity of games being that we will be able to rectify disappointments almost instantly, whilst building up some momentum and togetherness in the process.  The trick now will be to take this into the game against Wigan.

Player ratings:

Hart 6,  Zabaleta 6, Kolo Toure 8, Kompany 7, Bridge 7 (Boyata 6), De Jong 7, Barry 7, Yaya Toure 6, Silva 7 (Wright-Phillips N/A), Tevez 7 (Vieira N/A), Jo 7.

Man of the match: Kolo Toure

Wednesday, 15 September 2010

One month in, do we know our best eleven?

A month has now passed since the start of the Premier League and a pretty stable eleven has started to establish itself:

Hart

Richards, Kolo Toure, Kompany, Lescott

Barry, De Jong, Yaya Toure

Johnson, Milner

Tevez

However, to a great extent this has been forced by the injuries to Boateng, Kolarov and Balotelli, and the coming to fitness of David Silva.  Mancini was quoted in the week saying the following about Silva's start at City:

"I thought he did very well when he came on [against Blackburn] but I always said that he would need time because it is very different here than playing in Spain. The internationals are over now and I think it will be time for him to play in the team from the next game."
Which appears to say he is now ready to be a starter in the City team, in the Premier League as well as the Europa league.  He certainly looked bright against Blackburn, and we may need his class to make the most of the pressure we have been able to apply in the last two games.  If this is the case, then the very least it means is that one of Johnson, Milner, Barry, De Jong or Yaya Toure will have to make way.  Not the simplest of decisions.  It seems fairly evident that most of these five will have to get used to a small degree of rotation as the season progresses and we can always feel comfortable with whichever combination is put forward, but you have to presume there is a 'best eleven' in there somewhere.

I prattled on after the Blackburn game about getting the best out of Carlos Tevez and how the leading striker role does not suit him best:

I don't take issue with the 4-2-3-1 formation that was used, as it is favoured by most teams now and being a man light in the middle can lead to an uneven contest, but I don't think Tevez is at his best as the leading striker. Primarily because he doesn't act like one when he is played there. You cannot fault his energy and his ability to hold up the ball (which are both important in a leading striker role), but he almost never makes forward runs. Quite often a player will be breaking from midfield, Milner say, and Carlos will either run next to him or, more often than not, drop back - leaving the attacking midfielder with no option other than to cut-back on the attack or go it alone. He is much better as the man behind the strikers, where he can drop back, get involved and link up with the centre-forward. Because of his lack of forward runs, we often look like we are playing without a striker, in what is otherwise quite an attacking formation.

The issue here is that it will further complicate an already difficult choice in midfield. De Jong's knock and Barry's rest meant it appeared easier yesterday - with Milner allowed to start in his preferred central role - but, if Tevez is to drop back, Milner, Yaya Toure, De Jong, Barry and Vieira will have to battle over just two positions. Which is not an easy choice at all.

Obviously with Adebayor out and other candidates perhaps not quite up to it, Tevez will probably remain there for awhile - and therefore, this doesn't apply directly to yesterday's match, but it is a problem on the horizon and I don't think we will be fully effective until it is sorted out.
However, with the fear of sounding like a bit of a hypocrite, we don't have too much choice at the moment other than to play Tevez up front on his own.  Balotelli has increasingly depressing news about how far from action he might be; Adebayor is suffering from a small injury; Jo may not quite be the answer; and Roque Santa Cruz  is rarely available and seemingly a long way down the pecking order.  I still believe the decision to drop Tevez back should come at some point, but at the moment he will continue to lead the line.

If Silva is to come back in, it means a decision has to be made on who out of the midfielders should drop out.  With the will to retain a semblance of attacking football I think Milner and Johnson should remain untouched, leaving the tough decision between Barry, De Jong and Yaya Toure.  On current form, they have all staked their claim, but I don't think it would be too bad for Yaya Toure to get some of the Silva treatment - a bit of time to adapt to the English game in rotation with Barry and De Jong who, for me, have been too good to lose their places this season.  Yaya has shown glimpses of utter class on the ball in these early games, and it is hard to make that call, but whoever is left out would have huge grievances.

So, my choice for the best current eleven (before Boateng, Kolarov, and Balotelli return), would be the following in a 4-2-3-1 formation:

Hart

Richards,  Kolo Toure,  Kompany,  Lescott

De Jong, Barry

A. Johnson, Milner,  Silva

Tevez
 I guess the answer to the title of this piece is a resounding 'no' and I'm sure both Mancini and many of you will have wildly differing ideas about what would be the ideal solution to funnelling all our talent into eleven places.  Of course, the answer will be rotation, and many of the players can be interchanged with little effect to the strength of our team - so, it doesn't really matter as much as some people will have it whether Mancini knows his 'best eleven' or not.  The scope is there to adapt our team to suit the occasion and the sheer weight of games should see everyone involved, but come a big match, a cup final say, you would presume there is an eleven Mancini prefers...

Sunday, 12 September 2010

City 1 - 1 Blackburn: 4-2-3-1 is right but wrong; player ratings

To borrow a Mancini favourite: Football is strange. What, but for one moment of madness from our goalkeeper, could have been a fairly satisfying win, ends up leaving a feeling of frustration. An obstinate defence besides, I don't even think this was Blackburn at their best, so a point doesn't really feel like enough.

As the nation's darling of the moment, Hart will not face too great a criticism for his blunder yesterday - Match of the Day even over-emphasised Kolo Toure's role so much that Hart's actions may almost have sounded normal - but for all the points he has saved this season, these were ones he lost. Grella, who seemed to be willfully wasteful with the football up until their goal, punted a nothing ball forward, and Hart, to answer seemingly no danger whatsoever, decided to intervene in a situation that was already covered some twenty-five yards from goal. It was a moment of madness, and a calamitous way to concede your first goal from open play this season - and it set City the tough task of breaking through Blackburn and Paul Robinson. Hart has been exceptional this season and he will recover, but this should help him to keep a little more grounded.

Adam Johnson was our main threat in the first-half as City struggled to respond straight away - coming tantalisingly close with a curled shot across goal.

I don't take issue with the 4-2-3-1 formation that was used, as it is favoured by most teams now and being a man light in the middle can lead to an uneven contest, but I don't think Tevez is at his best as the leading striker. Primarily because he doesn't act like one when he is played there. You cannot fault his energy and his ability to hold up the ball (which are both important in a leading striker role), but he almost never makes forward runs. Quite often a player will be breaking from midfield, Milner say, and Carlos will either run next to him or, more often than not, drop back - leaving the attacking midfielder with no option other than to cut-back on the attack or go it alone. He is much better as the man behind the strikers, where he can drop back, get involved and link up with the centre-forward. Because of his lack of forward runs, we often look like we are playing without a striker, in what is otherwise quite an attacking formation.

The issue here is that it will further complicate an already difficult choice in midfield. De Jong's knock and Barry's rest meant it appeared easier yesterday - with Milner allowed to start in his preferred central role - but, if Tevez is to drop back, Milner, Yaya Toure, De Jong, Barry and Vieira will have to battle over just two positions. Which is not an easy choice at all.

Obviously with Adebayor out and other candidates perhaps not quite up to it, Tevez will probably remain there for awhile - and therefore, this doesn't apply directly to yesterday's match, but it is a problem on the horizon and I don't think we will be fully effective until it is sorted out.

All that said, we did create a number of chances to finish the game - some great last ditch defending from Blackburn prevented both Tevez and Jo after Silva had clipped them through; Robinson produced a good save from Barry; and Johnson could well have had a penalty after a great run into the box. But, for the second game running, City will be left rueing missed chances and dropped points.

Without Hart's blunder, we would be looking at a one-nil win that could've been more, with it, it is a frustratingly thwarted draw. The margins in football are very thin and matches hinge on such small events... 'Football is strange.'

Player ratings:

Hart 5, Richards 7, Kolo Toure 6.5, Kompany 7.5, Lescott 6, Wright-Phillips 6 (Jo 6), Vieira 6.5 (Barry 6.5), Yaya Toure 6, Milner 6.5, Johnson 8 (Silva N/A), Tevez 7.

Man of the match: Adam Johnson

Friday, 10 September 2010

City vs Blackburn - match preview

After the Sunderland game, the last thing Mancini would've wanted was a two week gap. All going to plan, City will play almost every three days all season - so to have a little break to stew over the failings against Sunderland will hopefully see everyone desperate to get back to winning ways.

The man who may be more desperate than most, Carlos Tevez, faces a late fitness test following a knock on international duty. He scored a hat-trick in this fixture last season - and other contenders, principally Adebayor, will really have to up their game to cover his possible absence.

Talk of Boateng making his long awaited debut seem to have been premature, with Mancini suggesting he is still some seven to ten days away from competitive football. At the end of the Sunderland game, we expected Boateng, Bridge and Balotelli to be fit for selection - but there will be no new faces in contention for a starting place.

Therefore the back four should remain the same - with Lescott continuing at left-back after his impressive display in the centre for England in the week. Micah missed international duty through illness, but he should be back - and he will be hoping the Blackburn defence will be as obliging to him as they were for his goal last January.

The man who provided the assist for that goal, Benjani Mwaruwari, could make his debut for Blackburn tomorrow. He will always be remembered for his City debut when (in case you need reminding!) he scored the winning goal at Old Trafford to seal a City double against United.

Blackburn have had a promising start to the season without too much to show from it. Victors against Everton on the opening day, they have since been unlucky to lose away to Birmingham, and lost narrowly against Arsenal. Allardyce, who quite wonderfully hasn't ruled himself out for the next England manager's position, has backed City's pursuit for honours, drawing parallels between City and successful Blackburn and Chelsea teams of the past two decades.

On loan rag Mame Diouf has four goals in his last two games, and rotund playmaker, David Dunn should now be fit enough to start for a Blackburn team that should be at full strength.

I know it won't happen, but I would like to see Adam Johnson on the left to see him terrorise Michel Salgado. Milner could do a similar job, but despite good showings for City and England, I don't think he looks at his most comfortable out there. You can't help but think that a tough decision is looming for Mancini over Milner, Yaya, Barry and De Jong - but the news of Balotelli's injury and Silva's gentle easing into Premiership life, could allow him to delay that decision a little longer.

I think Mancini will stick to the team that lost against Sunderland, with possession the key to wearing down a sturdy Blackburn defence, rather than trying to out-muscle them. To have the option of throwing on Silva and Adebayor will allow Mancini to exploit a tiring Blackburn resistance later on.

Possible line-up:

4-2-3-1

Hart

Richards, Kolo Toure, Kompany, Lescott

De Jong, Barry

Johnson, Yaya Toure, Milner

Tevez

However, we haven't seen the diamond formation yet that was used quite a lot in pre-season, which could result in a lack of width and the difficult dropping of a confident Johnson (who could be key tomorrow), but end with two-strikers and a more offensive looking line-up for a home fixture. I think home fixtures against teams outside the top five or six in the league were the occasions Mancini had planned this formation for, but Adam Johnson's international form may have persuaded him otherwise.

Blackburn are traditionally not as strong away from home, but they are sure to be resilient opponents, and patience may be the watchword again, as it is now that more and more teams grow to fear us! I remember Allardyce's press-conference at the first game of last season at Ewood Park, where he intimated that he would be happy with a home point from us, so I think it is fair to say a similar ambition may be applied to tomorrow.

Thursday, 9 September 2010

City don't mind cup-tieing Shaleum Logan; "Forza Milan"; Silva

With City's Europa League group stage kicking off properly next week against Red Bull Salzburg, another exclusive group of twenty-five has been announced for the first group phase. And again, one ever-present of the squads so far is Shaleum Logan - who didn't travel with the team to the USA in pre-season because he was taking trials with teams in the Championship. If he is to be involved sometime, perhaps in Turin once everything is already decided (one way or another!), then it would hinder him moving to another club involved in the Europa League...

Which is not the case for Roque Santa Cruz. Lazio are the tipped destination for Roque and they finished a good way off European football last season, so this would not harm a potential move there, but there is no reason to exclude other potential buyers. This is as clear a sign as any that Roque's City career is coming to a close - and perhaps, despite a place in the Premiership 25, that pushing him out before the September deadline would've been the ideal solution for both the player and for City.

City have also been obliged to name a second list that states the under-21 players that can be available should City need them. The full list is on the UEFA website, but the youngsters include: Boyata, Nimely, Ibrahim, Ben Mee, Scott Kay, Vidal and Benali. The rules are slightly different than the Premier League ones in that the young players still need to have been at City for a number of years to qualify for this second list - hence why Balotelli needs to be registered for the Europa League and not the Premier League.

In other news, Balotelli has emerged from surgery and his doctor has suggested that a rehabilitation period of six to eight weeks will be necessary before he can return to action - continuing a frustrating start to his City career. It didn't take too long for him to return to the Italian papers either - responding to Milan President Galliani's unhelpful comments by singing Milan songs out of the window. Galliani protested his innocence:

"As a child he was a Milan supporter. This morning I sent him a text message wishing him good luck, seeing as he’s one of our fans.

"Now that’s enough, otherwise we’ll create a diplomatic incident! At the very least I’d like to avoid causing trouble for Manchester City."


If I was being kind to him, I'd suggest he realised this last part just a little too late!

To complete a bit of a rambling post, the 'news' stories circulating suggesting Atletico Madrid are monitoring Silva could just as easily read 'Press are eagerly monitoring Silva for signs of unhappiness.' When he signed, Mancini suggested he would need a bit of time to adapt to the pace and brawn of the Premier League - so substitute and Europa League performances at this stage of the season should hardly be a surprise. He is evidently an enormously talented player, with the right attitude as well, so, needless to say, it is far, far too early for people to be expecting unrest. The fact that the Daily Mail article I read it in was only three lines long says it all.

Monday, 6 September 2010

Mixed messages from Lazio about Santa Cruz

Sky Sports ran a story today stating that Lazio are still in the market for Santa Cruz. They quote Lazio's sporting director, Igli Tare, saying:

"In January we will see if it is appropriate to make a transaction, perhaps with Santa Cruz."

Which backs up earlier claims from Claudio Lotito, the club's president, that they would still look at the possibility of signing him in the January transfer window.

This, however, was comically contradicted by reports from the Daily Mail that believe the Lazio coach, Edy Reja, vetoed the move due to 'some misgivings about Santa Cruz's tactical aptitude as well as his technical attributes.' In other words, he has misgivings about whether or not Santa Cruz is useless! It only really leaves Crocky room to be admired for his physical abilities, which would be considerable if reliability isn't an important factor.

Now, in Italy, it has been known for the coach to have a limited input on transfer dealings, so Reja's reported feelings about Santa Cruz may not matter too much. But Roque may have some work to do before January to impress upon Reja that his recent form has largely been the product of unreliable fitness.

Santa Cruz's agent was quoted as saying:

"Santa Cruz is a great professional and he will give everything for Manchester City."

In the 25 and with the games coming thick and fast this season, he should get the chance to prove this on the pitch - and I think Mancini would respond well to a fully committed and professional Santa Cruz. We need someone to lead the line and to act as a foil for Tevez and that is what Santa Cruz is made to do. He has shown few signs of becoming that man for City, but forever short on fitness and confidence, we certainly haven't seen the best of him either. He has everything to gain from showing the desire to be part of the team - whether it is to push his way closer to the City team, or just to prove to Reja that his failing body is worth the gamble in January.

August Awards

PLAYER OF THE MONTH: JOE HART

I can't look much further than Joe Hart for the Player of the Month. He immediately vindicated Mancini's faith in him with that outstanding display against Tottenham and, just as it seemed he would have a quiet night against Liverpool, he pulled off a wonderful double save that had the crowd leaping up and down as if City had just scored a goal. Solid and imposing, Hart has given the defence more confidence and has been the key man in a month when we have only conceded one goal - and that from the penalty spot.

Other contenders for the award include the midfield duo of Gareth Barry and Nigel de Jong - who have dominated midfield battles - and Vincent Kompany, who's partnership with Kolo Toure seems to be blossoming again this campaign.


GOAL OF THE MONTH: GARETH BARRY (vs Liverpool)


A sweeping end to an eighteen-pass move from Barry as he collected Milner's low cut-back. Our new possession football at its incisive best.


PERFORMANCE OF THE MONTH: 3-0 vs Liverpool


In front of Sheikh Mansour, City dominated Roy Hodgson's team and the flowing football defied all the worries about 'team-ethic' and 'gelling' that the press were lapping up after the draw at White Hart Lane.


DISAPPOINTMENT OF THE MONTH: Sunderland


City fell apart in the second half and were the complete antithesis of the patient, flowing side that appeared twice at Eastlands that week.


TAKE A LOOK AT YOURSELF: STEPHEN IRELAND


I wish him well at Villa, and I am sure he is bitter about leaving City, but his confused rant did more to satisfy City fans that his departure was the right move than anything we've seen in recent months. All the complaints about the young players who were obsessed with money were blatantly hypocritical, as well as his swipes at Michael Johnson's and Micah Richards' pay, but it was his arrogance that summed up the Ireland-conundrum. The 'I'm better than the new signings' and the 'I was always one of the best in training' comments. Everytime Ireland appeared on the pitch (where it matters afterall!), he showed nothing at all to support his supposed training performances. I was worried after his Player of the Season year that it would all go to his already fragile head, and the tippy-tappy performances that followed showed a return to an Ireland that undoubtedly has the ability, but doesn't have the head to use it. With regards to the mentality, Milner is the perfect juxtaposition. To see Ireland have an uncomfortable 6-0 drubbing of a debut just a day or two after his comments was good enough comeuppance for me. Now he can get on with rebuilding his career.


POINTS TOTAL (Premier League): 4 from 9


0-0 Tottenham (A)
1-0 Timisoara (A)
3-0 Liverpool (H)
2-0 Timisoara (H)
0-1 Sunderland (A)